How to Stop Medicare Scam Calls

Medicare scam calls are hard to stop completely, because scammers disguise their numbers and ignore the rules legitimate companies follow.

The best way to cut them down is to register with the National Do Not Call Registry, turn on spam-call blocking, and never give your Medicare number to someone who called you unexpectedly.

Our agency has been helping Medicare beneficiaries since 2011, and scam calls are one of the most common things clients ask me about.

Here's how to reduce these calls, recognize the scams, check whether a caller is real, and what to do if you already shared your information.

How to Stop Medicare Scam Calls

No single step stops every scam call.

But using several of these together makes a real difference.

Register at DoNotCall.gov

Sign up free at DoNotCall.gov or call 1-888-382-1222 from the phone you want to register.

This cuts down sales calls from legitimate companies, but scammers ignore it.

Turn on your phone's spam filtering

iPhones and Android phones both have settings to silence unknown callers or flag likely spam.

Spam filtering can help reduce unwanted calls, especially from numbers your phone identifies as suspicious.

In my experience, clients often find that screening unfamiliar numbers makes unwanted calls much easier to manage.

Ask your phone carrier about call blocking

Most major carriers offer free spam-call protection, and some offer paid upgrades.

If you have a landline, ask about the options for that too.

Let unknown numbers go to voicemail

If you aren't expecting a call, there's no need to pick up.

Legitimate callers can leave a message, and you can return the call using a number you've verified.

Hang up when someone pressures you

Urgency is the biggest red flag.

You don't owe a caller an explanation. Just end the call.

Report the call

Report unwanted calls to the FTC, and report suspected Medicare fraud to HHS-OIG.

The reporting table below shows where each type of report should go.

About FTC reports: they help investigators spot calling patterns and build cases.

A single complaint won't necessarily lead to action against that caller, but reports from many people do add up.

Most Common Medicare Phone Scams

Scammers rotate their scripts, but most calls fit one of these patterns.

"New Medicare card"

"Medicare is sending out new cards. I just need to verify your number."

Medicare doesn't need you to confirm your number over the phone to send a card.

Free medical equipment

"You qualify for a free back brace or diabetic supplies."

Your Medicare number is the real target. It's then used to bill Medicare for things you never needed.

"Your benefits are expiring"

"You'll lose coverage unless you verify your information today."

Medicare doesn't end your coverage through a surprise phone call. You also don't have to re-enroll every year.

Fake Medicare representatives

"I'm calling from Medicare about your account."

Caller ID may even say "Medicare," because scammers can fake (spoof) the name and number.

Pushy plan offers

"There's a new plan with extra benefits. Let's switch you today."

A real agent works on your schedule. Learn how to spot a trustworthy Medicare agent.

Each script tries to get you to share personal information or make a quick decision before you can check anything.

If a call asks for either, treat it as suspicious until you've confirmed it on your own.

What I See Most Often

Scam calls spike every fall around Annual Enrollment, when people expect to hear about plan changes.

Scammers count on that timing to make their calls sound routine.

How to Tell if a Medicare Call Is Legitimate

Some calls about your Medicare are real. The trouble is that a scammer can claim to be any of them.

  • Medicare itself generally calls only in limited situations, such as returning a call you asked for.
  • Your health plan may contact you as an existing member, for things like a care reminder or a benefits update.
  • An agent you've worked with may follow up if you gave permission.
  • Caller ID and familiar details don't prove a call is real. Scammers can fake a number and may already know your plan's name.

Plans and agents generally aren't allowed to make unsolicited sales calls to Medicare beneficiaries without permission.

The safest rule: if you're unsure, hang up.

Then call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) or the member services number on your insurance card. Use a number you looked up yourself, not one the caller gave you.

What to Do if You've Already Been Scammed

If you've shared personal or financial information with a suspicious caller, act quickly.

The steps you take depend on what information you shared.

  • Call 1-800-MEDICARE to report it and ask whether you need a new Medicare number.
  • Contact the Senior Medicare Patrol at 1-877-808-2468 for free one-on-one help.
  • Check your Medicare Summary Notices or plan statements for services or equipment you never received.
  • If you shared bank or card details, call your bank right away.
  • If you shared your Social Security number, create a recovery plan at IdentityTheft.gov.

Don't let embarrassment slow you down.

These scammers are professionals, and reporting quickly limits the damage.

Where to Report Medicare Scam Calls

What happenedWhere to report it
Unwanted sales call or robocall, no money lost DoNotCall.gov
You lost money or have details about the scammer ReportFraud.ftc.gov
Suspected Medicare fraud or misuse of your Medicare number HHS-OIG at oig.hhs.gov or 1-800-HHS-TIPS
Questionable charges on your Medicare statement 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227)
You want help figuring out what to do next Senior Medicare Patrol at 1-877-808-2468

If you're not sure which one fits, start with 1-800-MEDICARE or your local Senior Medicare Patrol.

Either can point you to the right place.

If you're a Policy Guide client and get a call about your plan that doesn't feel right, call us at (888) 414-4547 and we'll help you check it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why am I getting so many Medicare spam calls?

People approaching Medicare eligibility may receive more insurance marketing calls.

Scammers also target older adults and people who may be unfamiliar with Medicare's rules.

Calls also tend to increase in the fall around enrollment season.

Does the Do Not Call Registry stop Medicare scam calls?

Not really. The registry tells legitimate telemarketers not to call you, but scammers ignore it.

Your phone's spam filtering and call-blocking features can provide additional protection against unwanted calls.

Does Medicare ever call you on the phone?

Rarely, and generally only when you've asked for a call back.

Medicare won't call out of the blue to ask for your Medicare number, which it already has.

What should I do if I gave a scammer my Medicare number?

Call 1-800-MEDICARE to report it and ask whether you need a new number.

Then watch your Medicare statements for charges you don't recognize. The Senior Medicare Patrol (1-877-808-2468) can help you through the process.

Is it safe to enroll in a Medicare insurance plan over the phone?

It can be. Enrolling through a licensed agent or an insurer is legitimate when you started the conversation or gave them permission to contact you.

Don't enroll with someone who called you out of the blue. Here's how to find a trustworthy Medicare agent.

Mark Prip

Since 2003, Mark Prip has been leading Policy Guide, Inc., providing knowledgeable information about Medicare, life insurance, and dental coverage to clients in over forty states. With extensive hands-on experience helping Medicare beneficiaries understand and select health coverage, he brings decades of practical industry knowledge and client support. Mark has held his Florida Health & Life Insurance License (E051889) since 2003. View his license profile on the Florida Department of Financial Services website.